Thursday, August 18, 2022
HomeUS NewsTwitter-Musk drama escalates as both sides hurl claims of unhealthy habits in...

Twitter-Musk drama escalates as both sides hurl claims of unhealthy habits in new filings – IHNS

The Twitter-Elon Musk saga continued this week, as the two occasions traded barbs in licensed filings ahead of a five-day trial that’s scheduled to begin out Oct. 17.

Newly launched licensed paperwork from authorized professionals representing Musk in a countersuit in opposition to Twitter declare the social media agency engaged in a scheme to “mislead patrons” by providing false numbers in financial filings with the Securities and Alternate Charge. Musk says Twitter’s platform has a minimal of double the number of bots the company claims in SEC filings and fewer “monetizable every day energetic clients” than claimed.

Twitter responded that the billionaire CEO of Tesla and SpaceX is making incorrect assumptions, and in the hunt for an excuse to once more out of his $44 billion settlement in April to buy the social neighborhood.

Both facet are establishing their case as they head to court docket docket in Delaware to resolve their preliminary dispute over whether or not or not Musk has to watch by means of with the deal.

The drama began in early April, when Musk disclosed a significant stake in Twitter. After Musk agreed to hitch Twitter’s board, he reversed course and in its place offered to buy the company or promote his Twitter holdings.

Twitter was initially in opposition to the deal, and sought one different route, nevertheless in the end obtained right here to an settlement to advertise to Musk for spherical $54.20 per share. After that, as a result of the market tanked and Twitter’s share worth declined, Musk started badmouthing Twitter in public in a clear effort to get out of the deal.

This can be a rundown of the latest developments based totally on new, and some beforehand confidential, filings to the court docket docket from every occasions:

Numbers ‘faraway from true’

In a licensed submitting, Musk accused Twitter of along with statements in its SEC disclosures that “had been faraway from true.” By the use of his firm laws company Skadden-Arps, Musk acknowledged that Twitter is “miscounting the number of false and spam accounts on its platform” to offer a rosy picture to patrons.

Musk has complained about scams, spam and bots on Twitter for years.

In a press launch saying his settlement to buy Twitter, Musk wrote that “defeating the spam bots,” was thought-about one among his goals and motivations for taking over the company.

Twitter responded in a separate submitting throughout the Delaware court docket docket this week that Musk and his workforce have “spent months trying to invent a spam disclosure downside and have found nothing.”

Unwell-defined metrics

Musk’s attorneys moreover acknowledged of their countersuit that Twitter’s “monetizable every day energetic clients,” or mDAU, are “not as intently tied to earnings as Twitter leads most people to contemplate.” They allege that Twitter doesn’t exactly make clear to shareholders or to Musk how they derive the essential factor metric of mDAU.

In response, Twitter acknowledged that Musk on no account launched up points about mDAU as a motive to terminate the deal.

Musk’s allegations about misleading mDAU statistics “are a newly invented litigating place,” Twitter’s authorized professionals wrote. Furthermore, Twitter acknowledged it “exactly discloses in its SEC filings” the way in which it defines the mDAU metric and its significance to the company. 

Reliance on filings

Musk acknowledged, in his countersuit, that he relied on Twitter’s SEC filings to ascertain particulars regarding the social neighborhood’s enterprise and challenges.

What Musk doesn’t say is that he’s been buddies for years with former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey. As IHNSreported in January 2020, the two executives even exchanged ideas about strategies to boost Twitter.

Musk moreover has a longstanding enterprise relationship with Silver Lake, a financial company run partly by Twitter board member Egon Durban. Silver Lake was an enormous and early backer of SolarCity, the place Musk was chairman, and was reportedly one among many firms advising Musk when he acknowledged he was considering taking Tesla private for $420 a share, and had “funding secured” to take motion.  

Twitter reiterated in its filings that the company’s “SEC disclosures are right” and that agency “misrepresented nothing.” Twitter acknowledged Musk’s claims “normally are usually not supported by any data.”

“Musk sought an urgent deal, undertook no due diligence, and offered a self-described ‘vendor nice’ merger settlement that contained no representations about false or spam accounts or mDAU,” the Twitter authorized professionals wrote.


Musk acknowledged Twitter rebuffed his workforce, failing useful over requested and wanted particulars about bots and spam on the platform. The criticism doesn’t level out that Musk has acknowledged he would possibly start a competing social media platform.

Twitter attorneys alleged that “Musk invents representations Twitter on no account made after which tries to wield, selectively, the in depth confidential information Twitter supplied him to conjure a breach of those purported representations.”

The authorized professionals acknowledged that Musk “incoherently asserts” that Twitter “breached the merger settlement by stonewalling his information requests.”

Double the bots

In accusing Twitter of getting a minimal of twice as many bots on its platform as the company disclosed, Musk’s workforce relied on “accounts seen on the Firehose using the School of Indiana Botometer machine,” the counterclaim says.

Twitter questioned Musk’s methods of analyzing spam and bots, notably the utilization of the Botometer machine. The authorized professionals wrote that this machine “applies completely completely different necessities than Twitter does and which earlier this yr designated Musk himself as extraordinarily vulnerable to be a bot.”

WATCH: Twitter licensed workforce subpoenas Elon Musk associates related to deal breakup


Most Popular